\n\n

Friday Frivolity: The Villa Vie Odyssey Odyssey

by | Nov 6, 2026 | Law | 0 comments

I’ve been wanting to write about this for a while. I decided to wait to see how things turn out, because I wasn’t sure I had a story. But now the 3 ½-year residential cruise has ended early and ignominiously in Cambodia, it is ripe pickings for a Friday Frivolity column. I should not that this Friday Frivolity is often about contracts-adjacent matters. This story involves multiple allegations of breach of contract, but it is a much bigger story. Hence frivolity. But the story also has as tragic cast. People lost their homes, and there is nothing frivolous about that. 

Two things about this story piqued my interest. First, I went on my first cruise in summer 2025, and I really liked it. The idea of a residential cruise has a strange attraction to me. Second, that attraction was, at first, enhanced when I learned more about the Villa Vie Odyssey cruise from one of my favorite podcasts, Hyperfixed. The podcast’s host, Alex Goldman, has been conducting periodic interviews with Joe Rhodes, one of the passengers on The Odyssey, the cruise ship that was supposed to set off in May 2024 as a residential cruise. Now that the cruise has ended, Alex has compiled the interviews and released them as a special episode. Joe tells the story without Alex’s mediation on his Substack,Unmoored, but Joe is just one of the many voices aboard ship, and I’ll link to some others below.

Joe explains that, while some of the passengers on The Odyssey bought their cabins, like condominiums, he rented his for $3500/month. That would be a very low price just for a hotel room, but in this case, the price includes meals, wifi, utilities, and access to all of the ship’s amenities, including onboard medical staff. From Joe’s perspective, there’s only one major problem: for the first four months of the cruise, the bar only carried Bud Light, Corona, and zero-alcohol Heineken. 

Well maybe there were a few other problems, such as a 4 ½ month delay before the ship actually sailed, during which time a lot of passengers were stranded in Belfast. And then, once they set sail, they made it about ten miles from the port before they had to drop anchor for four days, perhaps because they did not have permission to dock anywhere. Eventually, the ship did dock in Brest, France, but not at a regular dock for cruise ships. The owners could only get permission to dock in a commercial port (sorry if I don’t have the right maritime terms here), and the passengers were not permitted to disembark. They probably wanted to do so, because during the trip to Brest, the ship’s water supply had failed. First, they had no hot water, and then, overnight, they lost all water. Some passengers were unaware of the problem and used their toilets, leading to a certain odor in portions of the ship.

Okay, so there were some problems, but I’m sure the owners of the cruise line were on top of things and were eager to respond to their customers’ justified complaints. Well, actually, they responded to some of those complaints by cancelling the cruise for two squeaky wheels. One of them filed a federal suit against the company. The company filed a motion to dismiss, but claims for breach of contract, promissory estoppel, conversion, and unjust enrichment survived.

There are all sorts of interesting angles to this story. There’s real poignancy in the stories of passengers for whom a residential cruise was a life-long aspiration. Some of them sold everything they owned so that they could buy cabins aboard The Odyssey. The company advertised homes for life aboard the ship for sales prices starting at $230,000. The buyers then became investors in Villa Vie Residences, because if the company failed, they stood to lose their homes. Those buyers did not much like it when other passengers complained publicly in ways that might jeopardize the enterprise. Others, like Joe, were just renters, and the company made certain representations that it had not fulfilled. 

One major issue for a lot of the passengers was that the company had represented that passengers would be compensated at a rate of up to $200/day for the time they were stranded in Belfast before the ship launched. That offer was later reduced to $140/day because the company claimed the right to offset its own expenses for maintaining the ship during the four-month delay. The difference amounted to $8000/passenger.

Moreover, even though the ship recovered somewhat from its rocky first weeks, problems remained. The ship was old and difficult to maintain. Some rooms were sweltering hot at night while the ship was in the Caribbean, so there was no escape from the heat. Other parts of the ship were freezing cold. There were problems with the pool, and some amenities that the company had advertised never materialized.

This is the ship that became The Odyssey when it was sailing under the name Braemar
By Cavernia – CC BY-SA 4.0,

The final chapter comes from Sopheng Cheang, writing on HuffPo. Ultimately, according to the company, the dream was done in by rising fuel costs. Fuel prices are especially high in Asia, and the company claims that monthly prices per cabin rose from $1800 to between $6000 and $8000. Part of the problem might have been that there were only 200 passengers aboard the ship, which was built to hold as many as 650. According to a departing passenger, many passengers had left in recent months, due to unreliable internet, itinerary changes, and declining food quality. The company had also passed the hat, asking passengers to help pay for rising fuel costs.

The company issued a statement, saying that its “focus now is on supporting residents, crew, and employees,” but passengers report that they were given seven hours’ notice to disembark and received no support from the company. They were left on their own to make arrangements to leave Cambodia. On October 28, the company offered some assistance, about which you can read here (in the update at the bottom).

Some passengers are not ready to give up on the dream and are trying to organize to buy the ship themselves. I’m not ready to give up on the dream either, but it’s hard for me to see how the numbers add up. Joe paid $3500/month for his cabin. One of the departing passengers paid $120,000 and was told she would have hers for at least fifteen years. Even with fuel at $1800/month, I don’t see how the enterprise would stay in the black. $120,000 would not come close to covering even just the fuel costs over fifteen years. Even at $3500 a month, it’s hard to imagine that fuel costs are 50% of the company’s costs, given the passenger/crew ratio of 2/1.5. There may be additional fees that passengers pay, but they would have to be pretty hefty to make this venture profitable. The company has said it will file for bankruptcy.

For more accounts of the cruise, check out Kit and Randy Cassingham’s Residential Cruising. The most recent post, Will We Ever Get Our Property Back?  is eye-opening. It seems that the ship was transferred to a Norwegian investment firm and passengers were notified that anything they left on board was to be sent to Singapore. 

GeeksonTour.com provides the following list of YouTubers on board:

And the following list of bloggers on board:

Quite the rabbit hole!

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *