\n\n

Section 13-4062(3) of the Arizona Revised Statutes contains the Clergy-Penitent Privilege. It provides that “[a] person shall not be examined as a witness in the following case[]”:

A clergyman or priest, without consent of the person making the confession, as to any confession made to the clergyman or priest in his professional character in the course of discipline enjoined by the church to which the clergyman or priest belongs.

Typically, this privilege applies to a parishioner (etc.) who makes a confession to a priest (etc.). But would a statement by a pastor to a co-pastor trigger the privilege? That was the question addressed by the Supreme Court of Arizona in its recent opinion in Rodriguez-Ramirez v. State, 594 P.3d 1269 (Ariz. 2026).

In Rodriguez-Ramirez,

The defendant, Mario Rodriguez-Ramirez, founded a Phoenix church and served as its pastor; Jose Padron joined him as co-pastor about four years later. The two are brothers-in-law and have been friends for more than thirty years. In 2020, allegations surfaced that Rodriguez-Ramirez had sexually abused Padron’s thirteen-year-old niece.

In response to these allegations, Rodriguez-Ramirez and Padron met privately to discuss them. Padron recorded the conversation without Rodriguez-Ramirez’s knowledge or consent. During this conversation, Rodriguez-Ramirez admitted that he secretly watched the victim shower, hugged and kissed her, acknowledged that he “touched” her, and that “she’s a little girl” and “I know it’s not right.”

Padron shared the recording with the victim’s family and multiple members of the church congregation. The victim’s family subsequently reported the matter to law enforcement. In 2021, the State charged Rodriguez-Ramirez with several counts related to his alleged sexual abuse of the victim.

Before trial, “Rodriguez-Ramirez moved to suppress the recording and the transcript of his conversation with Padron, arguing that the Clergy-Penitent Privilege applied.” The superior court found that the privilege did not apply. Rodriguez-Ramirez then sought special action relief, leading to the Court of Appeals of Arizona finding that the privilege did apply. The State then filed a petition for review, claiming that this was “a matter of statewide importance likely to recur.”

The Supreme Court of Arizona granted that petition and found that the privilege did not apply. The court concluded that

The superior court reasonably found that the discussion centered on protecting Rodriguez-Ramirez’s reputation, addressing church administration, and minimizing the legal and practical consequences of the allegations made against him. The discussion even turned to the logistics of Rodriguez-Ramirez’s flight from law enforcement, in case Padron’s efforts to dissuade the victim’s parents from pursuing charges failed. The record contains reasonable evidence supporting those findings, and the court of appeals therefore erred in declining to defer to them.

Collectively, those findings establish that Rodriguez-Ramirez neither sought absolution from Padron nor intended that their communication remain confidential. His communication with Padron, therefore, did not constitute a confession as defined in Doe.