\n\n

Summary – In CBI v. Anil Dixit, the Supreme Court clarified the distinction between inspection and production of documents collected during investigation but not relied upon by the prosecution. The accused may inspect such material and seek production of specific records at the appropriate trial stage, or identify them through a jointly signed list for prompt production before the Trial Court. Investigating agencies cannot be compelled to produce documents they do not possess; the accused may obtain these independently, with their evidentiary value determined by the Trial Court. the ruling is significant as its document-specific approach balances access to potentially relevant defence material with the expeditious conduct of criminal trials.

Introduction

The right of an accused to access documents collected during investigation but not relied upon by the prosecution has been a vexed issue. Although Sections 207 and 208 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (“CrPC”) (now Sections 230 and 231 of the Bhartiya Nagrik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023), provide for the supply of documents to an accused, the position on documents that the prosecution chose not to rely upon has evolved through judicial interpretation, particularly in light of the right to a fair trial under Article 21 of the Constitution.

In V.K. Sasikala v. State [(2012) 9 SCC 771] and Manjeet Singh Khera v. State of Maharashtra [(2013) 9 SCC 276], the Court recognised that documents not relied upon by the prosecution may still be relevant to the defence. Subsequently, in In Re: To Issue Certain Guidelines Regarding Inadequacies and Deficiencies in Criminal Trials [(2021) 10 SCC 598], the Supreme Court directed that a list of the documents not relied upon and other material collected during an investigation be furnished to the accused.

While these decisions recognised the importance of disclosure, a question remained: is an accused entitled merely to a list of such documents or can they also seek their production. In Sarla Gupta v. Directorate of Enforcement [(2025) 7 SCC 626] (Sarla Gupta), the Supreme Court held that although an accused is entitled to a list of documents not relied upon at the stage of framing of charges, copies of such documents cannot ordinarily be sought at that stage.

It is against the backdrop of this evolving legal position that the Supreme Court in Central Bureau of Investigation v. Anil Dixit [Criminal Appeal No. 4618 of 2026, arising out of SLP (Crl.) No. 17158 of 2026], on September 25, 2026, examined the scope and timing of production of documents not relied upon. The decision is significant as it draws a distinction between permitting an accused to inspect material not relied upon and requiring the prosecution to produce specific documents at a particular stage of the proceedings. It also provides a procedural mechanism for identifying and securing documents that may be relevant for the defence, without delaying the trial.

Background

The dispute arose from an application filed by the accused, seeking production of various documents from the Central Bureau of Investigation (“CBI”). Aggrieved by the concurrent orders of the lower courts allowing the application, the CBI approached the Supreme Court. The principal issue before the Supreme Court was whether, and at what stage, an accused could seek production of documents collected during an investigation but not relied upon by the prosecution.

Supreme Court’s Findings

Inspection of documents and their production are distinct

The Supreme Court did not undertake a detailed reconciliation of the two previous decisions concerning an accused person’s right to seek production of documents – State of Orissa v. Debendra Nath Padhi [(2005) 1 SCC 568] and Sarla Gupta. Instead, it proceeded on the premise that an accused is entitled to documents available with the prosecutor to prepare the defence. The question, in the Court’s view, was when particular documents could be sought, given their nature.

It held that the accused could inspect documents not relied upon and seek production of specific records at the appropriate stage of trial, when the relevant witness was being examined by either the prosecution or the defence. The CBI was directed to keep the relevant files ready for this purpose. The Court also provided an alternative procedure. During inspection, the accused could identify the documents required, which would be reduced to writing and signed by both parties. The identified documents would then be produced before the Trial Court without delay, and only those documents would need to be kept available in Court during the trial.

The arrangement is noteworthy because it enables the accused to identify material considered necessary for defence without requiring the prosecution to produce the entirety of the documents not relied upon at the stage of framing of charges.

Documents claimed to be relevant to the defence

The Supreme Court further observed that if the documents sought were not available with the CBI, the accused could independently procure them and use them for defence. The Court specifically referred to the possibility of obtaining such documents under the Right to Information Act, 2005, or by examining an appropriate witness during defence evidence. Importantly, the Court left the assessment of the evidentiary value of these documents to the Trial Court.

Documents not available with the investigating agency

The Supreme Court, however, accepted that documents not available with the investigating agency could not be directed to be produced by it. The Court clarified that the accused had the liberty to obtain such material independently and establish its relevance and evidentiary value before the Trial Court.

Practical Implications of the Judgement

The decision provides significant guidance on the treatment of not relied upon documents, particularly in investigations involving extensive documentary evidence.

Firstly, the judgement recognises that the prosecution’s decision not to rely upon a document does not, by itself, conclude the question of its relevance to the defence. An accused may have a legitimate basis to examine material collected during investigation even if the prosecution does not propose to rely on it.

Secondly, the Court draws an important distinction between inspection and production. While inspection of voluminous material may be permitted at an earlier stage, the production of specific documents can be deferred until the relevant trial stage.

Finally, the judgement recognises a limitation inherent in any direction for production. An investigating agency cannot be compelled to produce documents that it does not possess.

At the same time, the decision must be understood within the limits of the questions considered by the Court. The Supreme Court expressly refrained from a detailed examination of its earlier decisions in Debendra Nath Padhi and Sarla Gupta. It did not, therefore, conclusively settle the broader question of an accused’s right to copies of all documents not relied upon at the stage of framing of charges. Its directions were tailored to the nature of the documents sought and the stage of the trial they were sought at.

Conclusion

The decision does not confer an unrestricted right upon an accused to obtain copies of every document collected during investigation before the charges are framed. Equally, it does not permit the prosecution’s decision not to rely upon a document to operate as an absolute bar to the accused examining that material.

Instead, the Court adopts a document-specific approach permitting inspection, enabling the identification of relevant records and providing for their production at the appropriate stage. The judgement thus recognises that access to potentially relevant material and the expeditious conduct of criminal proceedings need not be competing considerations, provided that the procedure for inspection and production is appropriately structured.