I have been doing this for nearly 40 years. I have read hundreds of answers to complaints. I have seen boilerplate. I have seen defense lawyers throw everything at the wall to see what sticks.
I have never seen anything like what Nara Organics just filed.
In two federal lawsuits brought on behalf of two babies who came down with infant botulism after drinking Nara’s powdered formula, Nara has pled 61 affirmative defenses in one case and 59 in the other. Sixty-one. And a remarkable number of them point the finger at the people who did nothing wrong: the moms and dads.
The babies
I.N. was born on March 1, 2026, in Olympia, Washington. His mother spent months researching formula before choosing Nara, because she wanted to give her son something “a little better.” He was a vigorous, healthy baby who could lift his head during tummy time.
In late May, he stopped eating. He could not lift his head. He could barely cry. On June 5 he was admitted to Mary Bridge Children’s Hospital in Tacoma, where his parents were told the toxin could weaken the muscles he breathed with and that an intensive care bed was ready if he needed it. He was on oxygen that first night. He was treated with BabyBIG flown in from California. He spent eleven days in the hospital and went home on a feeding tube. The FDA’s whole genome sequencing tied the botulism strain from his own body to a ByHeart patient, ByHeart base powder and four sealed cans of ByHeart formula, all made with milk powder from the same supplier and dryer.
The California Department of Public Health cultured the opened can of Nara formula from his family’s kitchen. It grew Clostridium botulinum type A.
W.G. is the Pennsylvania baby in the same outbreak. He was a healthy two-month-old who lost the strength to hold up his head and then the strength to feed. He went to the pediatric intensive care unit at Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia, a few points from the threshold for a breathing tube. His stool tested positive for botulinum toxin type A. His parents bought Nara formula at Target and through Nara’s own website.
The CDC declared the Nara outbreak over on August 27, 2026, finding that epidemiologic, traceback and laboratory data showed Nara’s formula was contaminated with C. botulinum and made infants sick. The FDA tied it to the same supply chain as the ByHeart outbreak months earlier: organic whole milk from Organic West Milk, spray dried by Dairy Farmers of America in Fallon, Nevada.
What Nara knew, and when
This is the part that makes my blood boil.
The ByHeart infant botulism outbreak broke in November 2025. By the time the CDC closed it, it counted 28 confirmed and 20 probable cases, 48 hospitalized babies across 17 states. By late January 2026, the FDA had identified whole milk powder as the suspected vehicle, and on January 28 the Associated Press named the suppliers: Organic West and DFA.
Those were Nara’s suppliers too.
By Nara’s own account, it learned from media reports in early 2026 that its milk came from the same supply chain implicated in the largest infant botulism outbreak ever recorded. It “reviewed” the situation. It relied on indicator testing for sulfite-reducing clostridia, not testing for botulism itself. And it decided its formula “could stay on the market.”
It warned no one. Not parents. Not pediatricians.
Nara had already told the world, in its January 7, 2026 launch announcement, that its screening was designed to “identify and prevent contamination from spore-forming bacteria — like those related to botulism.” It knew exactly what the risk was. It said so in a press release.
Both babies were born weeks after the AP named Nara’s suppliers. Both drank that formula from their first weeks of life.
Sixty-one defenses
Now Nara has been sued. And here is what it says.
It says the parents misused the formula. It says the parents altered or modified the formula. It says the parents used it “in contravention of warnings.” It says the parents “knowingly, voluntarily, and willfully assumed any and all risks.” In the Pennsylvania case it says, in so many words, that the parents “were negligent, careless, at fault,” and that their conduct “contribute[d] substantially” to their own baby’s injuries.
What risk did a mother assume when she mixed formula in a bottle? What warning did she ignore? There was no warning. That is the whole point. Nara knew its milk came from the botulism supply chain and chose to say nothing.
It says the parents failed to mitigate their damages. Both families rushed their sons to doctors again and again until someone figured out what was wrong.
It says the babies’ injuries may have been caused by “an allergic, idiosyncratic, or idiopathic reaction,” or by a “pre-existing condition.” The pre-existing condition was being three months old and drinking Nara formula. Infant botulism is not an allergy. It is a toxin made by bacteria in a baby’s gut after the baby swallows the spores.
It says the claims may be barred by the statute of limitations. These babies got sick this past spring.
It even says the parents cannot show they relied on anything Nara told them. Both mothers chose Nara precisely because of what Nara told them: organic, European-made, tested batch by batch, meeting “both U.S. and EU food safety standards, some of the strictest in the world.”
The spoliation defense
The one that really got me is spoliation of evidence. Nara says the families’ claims may be barred because they failed “to preserve evidence.”
Think about that in the Washington case. The Nam family handed their opened can to public health officials, and the state’s laboratory grew botulism from it. They gave three sealed cans from the same lot to the county health department, which sent them to the FDA. That family preserved everything. The evidence they preserved is the evidence that proves the case.
The Goldfins did the same thing they were asked to do: when the health department came, they handed over what they had, down to the residue in their formula dispenser. They had used up the cans bought before their son got sick because they were feeding a baby. That is what formula is for.
“Not foreseeable”
Nara also says the babies’ injuries “were not foreseeable” given “the state of scientific knowledge and state of the art.” That is breathtaking.
By the time these babies were drinking Nara formula, the FDA had written to the entire infant formula industry in 2023 naming C. botulinum as a historical hazard in powdered formula. The ByHeart outbreak had sickened dozens of babies. The FDA had traced it to whole milk powder. The AP had named Nara’s suppliers. And Nara had put botulism in its own press release.
After the outbreak, the FDA’s July 2026 letter to the industry told manufacturers that outbreak investigations “may serve as safety signals” and warned that ignoring or downplaying them can lead to illnesses that could have been avoided. Nara had that signal in January. It looked at it and kept selling.
And in Pennsylvania, Nara says its punitive damages exposure is barred because the formula was made “in accordance with the terms of the Food and Drug Administration’s approval.” The FDA does not approve infant formula. There is no approval.
Blaming everyone but itself
Then there is the crossclaim. In Pennsylvania, while denying it did anything wrong, Nara sued Organic West and DFA, alleging that their “acts, omissions and/or product(s)” were “the primary cause” of the damages.
So, Nara agrees the milk powder was the problem. It just does not want to be the one responsible for selling it to babies after it knew where the powder came from.
I understand that defense lawyers plead defenses to preserve them. I have been on the receiving end of boilerplate my whole career. But there is a difference between preserving a defense and accusing the parents of a paralyzed infant of misusing, altering and assuming the risk of baby formula. Rule 11 requires that defenses have factual support or be likely to have it after discovery. Nara will have to show us the facts behind every one of these. We will be asking. We will also be asking the Court to hold its lawyers accountable.
What this tells us
When the FDA, CDC and two state laboratories have traced your product to a botulism outbreak, and your own supplier sits at the center of an earlier outbreak you knew about, you have a choice. You can own it. Or you can file 61 defenses and blame the parents.
Nara chose the second. Juries in Tacoma and Philadelphia will get to decide what they think of that.
These families did everything right. They researched. They chose what they thought was the safest formula on the market. They fed their sons. And they watched those boys lose the strength to lift their heads.
They deserve better than to be called careless by the company that sold them the can.
Recent Comments