It was another exciting morning for Stan Woodward, the omnipresent associate attorney general, who got reamed out by Judge April Perry in Chicago for being very bad at law … again.
Woodward’s entire job consists of parachuting in to courtrooms where the government is in trouble and making matters so much worse. In Chicago, US Attorney Andrew Boutros’s office was already flailing after being forced to dismiss charges against the “Broadview 6” for obstruction of a government official in the conduct of his duties, i.e., getting hit by an ICE agent’s car in the middle of a protest. The government spent months indignantly denouncing the allegations of prosecutorial misconduct as “fevered paranoia and delusional speculation.” But the unsealed grand jury transcripts showed three separate presentations to the same panel in October of 2025, each of which was plagued by obvious impropriety.
In open court, USA Boutros assured Judge Perry that he only discovered the problem five months later. And his office assured the court that they’d had no discussions with Main Justice about the case.
Turns out … not so much.
Boutros was emailed a copy of the first grand jury transcript, with vouching on the first page, five days later. As Judge Perry noted, he would have had to approve re-presenting the case after a no-bill, and it’s “unfathomable” that he would have done so without “the best evidence available to him about what went wrong in the grand jury.” And in August, the government conceded there had been ‘discussions’ with Main Justice about ‘case updates,’ and earlier this month the former head of the FBI’s Chicago office alleged in a lawsuit that Boutros met with Ag Todd Blanche and FBI Director Kash Patel about the case.
On the afternoon of October 30, 2026, just hours before a response to Judge Perry’s request for information was due, Woodward and his sidekick Enrique Carniero clocked in, and two other AUSAs clocked out. He proceeded to docket a lecture on the court’s inherent powers, scolding Judge Perry that she was obligated to turn any investigation of misconduct by DOJ lawyers over to the DOJ itself.
This was followed by three weeks of wide-eyed requests for “clarification,” interspersed with sneering denunciations of the judge’s “freewheeling, quasi-inquisitorial, quasi-prosecutorial ‘inquest.’”
Last night, hours before the AUSAs were due to hand Judge Perry in camera proffers of their testimony — including whatever DOJ claims is privileged — Woodward struck again.
“The United States moves for the referral to a special master or an otherwise disinterested judicial officer to conduct preliminary rulings on privilege,” he wrote, adding that “a neutral arbiter is required to rule on privilege disputes that may arise in said inquiry.”
“The Court has assumed an executive-branch function, so unless it abandons that function, it may not also retain the judicial power to rule on questions of privilege,” Woodward huffed.
As an incandescently pissed off Judge Perry pointed out in a minute order this morning, the government’s brief played a little fast and loose with the caselaw:
As the Court noted earlier this week — and the cases cited by the Government uniformly hold — ruling on questions of privilege is a judicial function. See, e.g., In re Search Warrant Issued June 13, 2019, 942 F.3d 159,176 (4th Cir. 2019) (holding that resolution of privilege disputes “is a judicial function”). Similarly, it is standard practice for judges to rule on motions regarding the admission of evidence in proceedings where the judge is also the factfinder — including
during suppression hearings and bench trials. The Seventh Circuit has noted its faith in a
judge’s ability to do so. See, e.g., Ashford v. Gilmore, 167 F.3d 1130, 1136 (7th Cir. 1999)
(“[T]he law presumes that judges are not influenced by improper evidence brought before
them.”); In re Salem, 465 F.3d 767, 777 (7th Cir. 2006) (noting that “where the factfinder
and the gatekeeper are the same, the court does not err in admitting the evidence subject to
the ability later to exclude it or disregard it”).
On top of which, a special master would be supervised by the judge, who would review any of his rulings de novo, including any dispute over privileged discovery.
And, not for nothing, but submitting yet another eleventh hour filing after getting called out by the judge for “gamesmanship” is a choice.
“The Government has known for more than five months that the Court planned to hold a hearing regarding the conduct of the federal prosecutors in this matter, and for more than three months that potentially privileged communications would be at issue during that hearing,” Judge Perry fumed. “Despite this, the Government waited until 6:50 p.m. the night before potentially privileged materials would be tendered to the Court to file its motion. The request is therefore untimely.”
But other than that, BANG UP JOB, STAN!
So …
The AUSAs are due to hand Judge Perry their proffers today. DOJ has until Tuesday to explain why she shouldn’t get to read them. And everyone is due back in court on December 2.
Will Main Justice let its own prosecutors take the stand? Or will it run to the Seventh Circuit, screaming about some privilege or other as a tiny figleaf to cover its naked contempt?
US v. Rabbitt [Docket via Court Listener]
Liz Dye produces the Law and Chaos Substack and podcast. You can subscribe by clicking the logo:
The post DOJ Demand To Hide Misconduct Inside Special Master Fails To Impress Judge appeared first on Above the Law.
Recent Comments