\n\n

Over at The Forward, Michael A. Helfand and Chaim Saiman (below) tell the story of Strulovitch v. Bain, a dispute that started in a Jewish religious (halachic) adjudicatory body and found its way to the U.S. Supreme Court. Justice Sotomayor, who is the Justice for the Second Circuit, told the petitioner to go away for now, but he can try again at some point later.

Professor Michael Helfand
Professor Chaim Saimon

Professors Helfand and Simon live and breathe this stuff, so you should go their Forward article to get the full story. The short version is:

  • The case started as a commercial dispute over ownership in a nursing home that was resolved in a beit din;
  • Some of the potential owners of the business had never consented to arbitrate before the beit din, so they ran to a Westchester County state court to enjoin the enforcement of the beit din;
  • Strulovitch summoned Bain before the beit din, Bain ran to the court to seek an order enjoining any further proceedings while the state case was pending, and Westchester County Justice Jamieson granted that second injunction;
  • The beit din somehow learned of this and, apparently sua sponte, issued a seruv against Bain, akin to an order of contempt, which can lead to shunning of the person subject to it;
  • Justice Jamieson then ordered Strulovitch to “take all steps necessary” to have the seruv withdrawn.

In that final order, Justice Jamieson ventured into First Amendment territory, as the seruv is a matter of religious law. Strulovitch sought relief from the U.S. Supreme Court. I was curious how Strulovitch got from a state trial court to the U.S. Supreme Court. According to his cert. petition, he had exhausted all avenues of relief in the New York Court system. As noted above, Justice Sotomayor denied for now. I’m also curious about what Justice Jamieson thinks Strulovitch can do to get the seruv withdrawn. He didn’t ask for it, so why should the beit din listen to him when he asks it to take action?

Thanks to Alexa Cameron-Windsor for sharing the story with me.