Although the policy application did not specifically request withheld information, it was deemed material information that the insured should have disclosed. Hence, the California Court of Appeal held that the policy was property rescinded. Passport 420, LLC v. Starr Indem. & Liab. Co., 2026 Cal. App. LEXXIS 611 (Cal. Ct. App. Oct. 1, 2026).
Passport 420 LLC was formed by attorney Michael Avenatti and his client, William Parrish. The two decided to buy a jet together. Avenatti embezzled approximately two million dollars from a client and used the money to pay for his share of the aircraft’s purchase price.
After the jet was purchased, Passport hired Christopher Ohman, a commercial pilot, to fly and manage the maintenance of the jet. Ohman completed an application to obtain an aircraft insurance policy from Starr.
The application requested information identifying the aircraft, the qualification of its pilots and the arrangements made to maintain it. It also requested information regarding any liens or loans secured by the aircraft. The application did not, however, request any information regarding the source of the funds used to purchase the aircraft, the financial condition of Passport, or the finances of its individual members. Nevertheless, Starr contended it would not have insured an aircraft if it was aware the aircraft had been purchased with illegal funds.
Subsequently, the United States Treasury Department seized the aircraft. Avenatti was indicted for wire and bank fraud the same day. Parrish submitted a sworn proof of loss statement to Starr seeking to recover $3,900,000, the insured value of the aircraft less the $10,000 deductible.
Starr denied the claim and purported to rescind the policy after Avenatti’s criminal case ended with his conviction. The denial letter relied on the evidence of Avenatti’s crimes and “Passport 420’s concealment of material facts from Starr during the underwriting process – specifically, that the aircraft was purchased with stolen funds . . .”
Passport filed suit against Starr. The trial court denied Starr’s motion for judgment at the close of Passport’s case. The jury found in favor of Passport, awarding both compensatory and punitive damages.
The Court of Appeal concluded the trial court erred when it denied Starr’s motion for judgment because Passport concealed the material fact that Avenatti embezzled funds used to purchase the aircraft and his knowledge of that fact was imputed to Passport. The Starr underwriter testified that the use of embezzled funds to purchase the aircraft was a material fact and that Starr would not have issued the policy had it known the truth.
Passport argued the embezzlement was not a material fact because Starr did not inquire about it or any other aspect of Passport’s finances. By California statute, the insurer had no duty to inquire about a material fact unless the fact was distinctly implied from other facts that had been revealed, or the insurer had actual knowledge that facts presented in an application were untrue. Because the use of embezzled funds vastly increased the risk of a government seizure, any rational insurer would decline to insure the property, exclude government seizure from the policy, or require an increased premium in exchange for the increased rise.
Finally, Avenatti’s knowledge of his crimes was imputed to Passport. As a consequence, Passport concealed the material fact of the embezzlement from Starr. Starr was entitled to equitable rescission of the policy.
Recent Comments