\n\n

Despite the insured’s argument that the policy’s enforcement of the law or ordinance exclusion should not apply because the city demolished the insured’s building without due process, the court agreed with the insurer that coverage was properly denied, relying partly on a case from the Hawaii Supreme Court. Revive Nightlife Group, LLC v. City of Youngstown, 2026 Ohio App. LEXIS 3606 (Ohio Ct. App. Sept. 29, 2026).

The insured owned a building that the fire chief determined was structurally unsound. An order under city ordinances authorizing emergency demolitions was issued. The city then demolished the building. The insured submitted a claim to its insurance company, but coverage was denied based upon an exclusion for loss from a government-ordered demolition. The exclusion barred coverage for,

The enforcement of any ordinance or law . . . (2) Requiring the tearing down of any property, including the cost of removing the debris.

The insured sued the city and its insurer. The complaint claimed the city’s posting of notice at the property constituted insufficient process and challenged the constitutionality of the city’s emergency demolition ordinances. The insurer was sued for breach of contract and bad faith based on the denial of the claim.

The insurer moved for summary judgment arguing that the exclusion barred coverage. The insured argued the exclusion barred coverage only if the fire chief’s demolition order was valid, but if his order was invalid, then the demolition was an act of vandalism. The trial court granted summary judgment for the insurer and the insured appealed.

The insured argued that the exclusion should not apply if the government enforcement or order failed to involve an actual emergency and failed to comply with federal constitutional notice requirements. The insured further argued that the existence of the demolition order was not necessarily the cause of the loss. The actual cause could be the lack of due process or an improper emergency finding through recklessness resulting in trespass and vandalism by the city.

The court noted, however, that the exclusion applied to loss or damage “caused directly or indirectly” by ordinance enforcement and government order. Further, the exclusion was preceded by the warning, “Such loss or damage is excluded regardless of any other cause or event that contributes concurrently or in any sequence to the loss.”

The insured argued the enforcement of an ordinance leading to a demolition necessarily carried the modifier of lawful and thereby necessarily did not exclude any enforcement or order that lacked due process and was not an emergency or was ambiguous as to whether it excluded such enforcements or orders by the government.

However, the exclusion did not specify the enforcement or order must be lawful. The exclusion covered all enforcements of ordinances or laws and all orders of governmental authority, both those performed perfectly proper and those alleged by the insured to be improper for some reason.

The court relied upon a decision from the Hawaii Supreme Court, Hawaii Land Co. v. Lion Fire Ins. Co., 13 Haw. 164 (1900). There, the court pointed out the exclusion applied where the official purported to act in his power under a law providing apparent authority because in the exclusion, “Nothing is said about the order being lawful and it could not have been the intention of the insurer in inserting the clause in the policy to make its exemption from liability depend on the solution of nice questions as to the lawfulness of the orders of the civil authorities.” Id. at 166.

Whether the notice from the fire chief was constitutionally sufficient and whether an emergency situation actually existed did not change the clear language of the policy exclusion.

Finally, the court found that the plain language of the policy showed the denial of the claim was not in bad faith.