If I was a leader at the FDA or in Congress I would not let this happen, or I would make damn sure it did happen
Congress has about four weeks to decide whether the Food Traceability Rule survives in a form that works. The decision will not be announced. It will happen in the text of whatever funding bill passes before the stopgap expires on December 11, and it will turn on whether one section, Section 780, is carried forward or left behind. This post is about what needs to be done, why it matters, and the dates that govern it.
What Section 780 does
Section 780 of the fiscal year 2026 agriculture appropriations act bars FDA from using appropriated funds to administer or enforce the Food Traceability Rule, 21 C.F.R. Part 1, Subpart S, before July 20, 2028. It also directs FDA to identify “additional flexibilities” in the rule’s lot-level tracking requirements.
The first part changed nothing. FDA had already moved the compliance date from January 20, 2026 to July 20, 2028 by regulation in August 2025. The second part is new, and it is the reason this matters. The traceability lot code, assigned where food is first packed and carried through every shipping, receiving and transformation step to the store or restaurant, is the only element of the rule that shortens a traceback. Everything else is paperwork. Tell FDA to be flexible about the lot code and you have told it to keep the paperwork and lose the point.
Why it matters now
This summer more than 20,000 people were sickened with Cyclospora in an outbreak linked to lettuce served at Taco Bell restaurants. My firm represents many of them. The traceback took weeks, and a large part of the delay came from a familiar gap: the records between the packer and the restaurant did not carry a lot code that matched the one assigned at the start. Investigators read invoices instead of pulling product. Every week of traceback was a week of exposure.
Lot-level records would not have kept the parasite off the lettuce. They would have shortened the outbreak and narrowed the recall. That is what Congress asked for when it wrote section 204(d) of the Food Safety Modernization Act in 2010 and told FDA to issue the rule by January 2013. Enforcement is now set for July 2028. Fifteen and a half years is long enough.
The companies that asked for the delay are named in their own filings, and I have written about who they are and which members of the subcommittee that funds FDA wrote the bill. Several of their competitors built lot-level systems to the original 2026 date and say the systems work. The question is no longer whether it can be done. The answer is on the shelves of the companies that did it.
The calendar
Three dates matter.
Early December: the FDA docket closes. FDA held public meetings on June 15 and November 6 on “challenges and solutions in lot-level food traceability” and is taking written comments in docket FDA-2014-N-0053. The comment period closes in early December; check the docket for the exact day. This is the record FDA will cite when it decides what “flexibility” means.
December 11: the stopgap expires. The continuing resolution now in effect carries Section 780 forward on last year’s terms. The House-passed fiscal 2027 agriculture bill, H.R. 8646, passed June 4 by a vote of 213 to 210 and carries the rider again. The Senate has not marked up its bill. Whatever Congress passes to keep the government open either carries Section 780 into 2027 or lets it lapse.
January 3: the new Congress. Section 780 limits only funds “appropriated by this Act.” It does not need to be repealed. It needs to be left out of the next act. A new majority writing a full-year bill can simply not include it.
What needs to happen
At FDA. The agency should say, in whatever comes out of the November meeting, that flexibility will be limited to how firms keep and transmit records, not what they must record. The lot code travels with the food or the rule does not work. FDA should also use the time before 2028 to build the system GAO reported in January it does not yet have: a way to receive a sortable spreadsheet within 24 hours and read it. I am filing a comment in the docket this week saying exactly that, and anyone who cares about this should file one too. A paragraph is enough.
In the lame duck. The Senate agriculture appropriations subcommittee, Chairman Hoeven and Ranking Member Shaheen, should leave Section 780 out of its bill. If the vehicle is another continuing resolution, the rider should be dropped from it or allowed to expire with it rather than carried into 2027. If it must stay, the “additional flexibilities” sentence should be struck and the words “full enforcement no later than July 20, 2028” put in bill text where they cannot be read away. I have asked Congresswoman DeLauro, who will chair the House Appropriations Committee in January, to make it a condition of the year-end deal.
In statute. A short bill should be introduced now that puts the lot code and the 2028 date in the Food Safety Modernization Act itself and requires any future appropriations rider that changes them to say so expressly. It will not pass in December. Introduced now, it gives the new Congress a number and cosponsors on day one, and it gives FDA a reason to hold the line this month.
From the people who already do it. The leafy greens growers in California and Arizona have kept lot-level records under their marketing agreements for years. They are the ones named in regional advisories when a traceback fails. A public statement from them that lot-level traceability works, and that the industry’s interest is in a rule that names a lot instead of a region, would do more to answer the “cannot be done” argument than anything I can write. I have asked.
What I am asking of you
If you run a company that complies with the rule today, say so, in the docket and to your senators. If you work for one of the consumer, public health or labor groups that signed the August 12 letter asking Congress to rescind the rider, file a comment and send the letter again. If you got sick this summer, or your child did, your senators’ offices need to hear from you before December 11, not after.
I have been asking the produce industry to put me out of business since a lunch with the Salinas growers in February 2007. A traceability rule with lot codes intact, enforced in July 2028 and not a day later, is one of the few things that would actually do it.
The rule has been law since 2022. Nobody has had to follow it. The next four weeks decide whether anyone ever will.
Recent Comments